EchoMTG Logo
Dashboard / Home
My Collection
Magic: the Gathering logo
Magic: the Gathering
MTG Expansions
MTG Market
Special Groups
MTG Types
Disney Lorcana logo
Disney Lorcana
My Apps
Lists / Decks
Sealed Manager
Earnings Tracker
Watchlist
Trade List
Statistics
Import Tool
My Account
EchoMTG
Blog
API Docs
Subscription Plans
Login
EchoMTG Logo
Background O,age

Magic: the GatheringMost Expensive Magic: the Gathering horrors

Top 87 Most Expensive horrors
Background

Track Prices

Collection tools for Magic: the Gathering, no ads, track a binder worth the cards for free.

Search cards...
Filter by Type
Card Info
Rarity
#
7-day
Regular Price
Foil Price
Sauron, the Dark Lord (Borderless Poster) card image
3ubrSauron, the Dark Lord (Borderless Poster)Legendary Creature — Avatar HorrorThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth
Mythic Rare
744
$300.28
$382.06
Thalia and The Gitrog Monster (Winner) card image
Thalia and The Gitrog Monster (Winner)legendary creature — human frog horrorGame Day Promos
Promo
12
$156.6
Solphim, Mayhem Dominus card image
2rrSolphim, Mayhem DominusLegendary Creature — Phyrexian HorrorPromo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One
Mythic Rare
150
2 %
$87.15
$18.86
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice (Borderless) card image
gwubAtraxa, Praetors' Voice (Borderless)Legendary Creature - Angel HorrorDouble Masters
Mythic Rare
353
$54.97
$63.97
Toxrill, the Corrosive card image
5bbToxrill, the CorrosiveLegendary Creature — Slug HorrorPromo Pack: Dominaria United
Mythic Rare
132
2 %
$51.86
$31.31
Zellix, Sanity Flayer (Extended Art) card image
2uZellix, Sanity Flayer (Extended Art)Legendary Creature — HorrorCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate
Mythic Rare
619
3 %
$44.14
$25.44
Mondrak, Glory Dominus card image
2wwMondrak, Glory DominusLegendary Creature — Phyrexian HorrorPhyrexia: All Will Be One
mythic
23
5 %
$42.89
$35.72
Hell's Caretaker card image
3bHell's CaretakerCreature - HorrorLegends
Rare
104
$41.01
Mind Flayer, the Shadow card image
4bbbMind Flayer, the ShadowLegendary Enchantment Creature — HorrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
340
$40.99
$52.04
Overlord of the Balemurk (Extended Art) card image
3bbOverlord of the Balemurk (Extended Art)enchantment creature — avatar horrorDuskmourn: House of Horror
Mythic Rare
377
5 %
$33.9
$28.91
Gisela, the Broken Blade (Display Commander) - Thick Stock card image
2wwGisela, the Broken Blade (Display Commander) - Thick StockLegendary Creature — Angel HorrorSecret Lair Drop
Mythic Rare
1387
1 %
$33
Umbris, Fear Manifest card image
3ubUmbris, Fear Manifestlegendary creature — nightmare horrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
2324
4 %
$29.18
Hullbreaker Horror card image
5uuHullbreaker Horrorcreature — kraken horrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Rare
2321
9 %
$28.79
Phyrexian Vindicator card image
wwwwPhyrexian VindicatorCreature — Phyrexian HorrorPromo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One
Mythic Rare
27
$27.79
$5.71
The Gitrog Monster (Borderless) card image
3bgThe Gitrog Monster (Borderless)Legendary Creature — Frog HorrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
1051
-1 %
$27.47
$25.73
Sauron, the Lidless Eye (Extended Art) card image
3brSauron, the Lidless Eye (Extended Art)Legendary Creature — Avatar HorrorThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth
Mythic Rare
396
3 %
$26.03
Gary, the Snail - Toxrill, the Corrosive card image
5bbGary, the Snail - Toxrill, the Corrosivelegendary creature — slug horrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
1929
3 %
$20.99
Bruna, the Fading Light (Display Commander) - Thick Stock card image
5wwBruna, the Fading Light (Display Commander) - Thick StockLegendary Creature — Angel HorrorSecret Lair Drop
Mythic Rare
1388
1 %
$19.99
Krovikan Horror card image
3bKrovikan HorrorCreature - Horror SpiritAlliances
Rare
53
1 %
$19.96
Post, Son of Rich - K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth card image
4bbbPost, Son of Rich - K'rrik, Son of YawgmothLegendary Creature — Phyrexian Horror MinionSecret Lair Drop Series
Rare
1186
-1 %
$19.34
$21.95
Captain N'ghathrod (Extended Art) card image
3ubCaptain N'ghathrod (Extended Art)Legendary Creature — Horror PirateCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate
Mythic Rare
640
$16.81
$80.37
Brainstealer Dragon card image
5bbBrainstealer DragonCreature — Dragon HorrorOutlaws of Thunder Junction Commander
rare
127
-5 %
$15.23
Overlord of the Hauntwoods card image
Overlord of the Hauntwoodsenchantment creature — avatar horrorPromo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Mythic Rare
194
$15.2
$16
Phyrexian Negator card image
2bPhyrexian NegatorCreature - HorrorUrza's Destiny
Rare
65
$15.11
$181.59
Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus card image
5ggZopandrel, Hunger DominusLegendary Creature — Phyrexian HorrorPromo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One
Mythic Rare
195
2 %
$15.04
$12.79
Eddie, Ghost of the Navigator - Captain N'ghathrod card image
3ubEddie, Ghost of the Navigator - Captain N'ghathrodlegendary creature — horror pirateSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
2183
2 %
$14.94
Spellskite (2325) card image
2Spellskite (2325)artifact creature — phyrexian horrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Rare
2325
$14.78
Phyrexian Obliterator card image
bbbbPhyrexian ObliteratorCreature — HorrorThe List
Mythic Rare
101
$14.13
Cosmic Horror card image
3bbbCosmic HorrorCreature - HorrorLegends
Rare
92
1 %
$13.14
Sauron, Lord of the Rings (Showcase Scrolls) card image
5ubrSauron, Lord of the Rings (Showcase Scrolls)Legendary Creature — Avatar HorrorTales of Middle-Earth Commander
Mythic Rare
478
$12.99
$15.67
Aboleth Spawn (Extended Art) card image
2uAboleth Spawn (Extended Art)Creature — Fish HorrorCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate
Rare
612
9 %
$11.15
Drivnod, Carnage Dominus card image
3bbDrivnod, Carnage DominusLegendary Creature — Phyrexian HorrorPromo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One
Mythic Rare
90
1 %
$10.98
$7
Prime Mirelurk Queen - Hullbreaker Horror (Showcase) card image
5uuPrime Mirelurk Queen - Hullbreaker Horror (Showcase)Creature — Kraken HorrorUniverses Beyond: Fallout
rare
344
-1 %
$10.68
$9.85
Phyrexian Negator - 1999 Jakub Slemr (UDS) card image
2bPhyrexian Negator - 1999 Jakub Slemr (UDS)Creature - HorrorWorld Championship Decks
Mythic Rare
.
$10.64
Armaggon, Future Shark (Extended Art) card image
6bbArmaggon, Future Shark (Extended Art)legendary creature — shark horror mutantTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Rare
264
$9.81
Chasm Skulker card image
2uChasm SkulkerCreature - Squid HorrorPromo Pack: Ikoria
Rare
46
$8.52
$21.3
Hordewing Skaab (Extended Art) card image
4uHordewing Skaab (Extended Art)Creature — Zombie HorrorCommander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt
Rare
53
3 %
$8.49
Overlord of the Mistmoors card image
Overlord of the Mistmoorsenchantment creature — avatar horrorPromo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Mythic Rare
23
-1 %
$8.04
$12.57
Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus (Showcase) card image
2uuTekuthal, Inquiry Dominus (Showcase)Legendary Creature — Phyrexian HorrorPhyrexia: All Will Be One
Mythic Rare
302
9 %
$7.81
$11.24
Ravenous Chupacabra card image
2bbRavenous ChupacabraCreature — Beast HorrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Rare
305
-1 %
$7.17
Kederekt Parasite card image
bKederekt ParasiteCreature — HorrorThe List
Rare
48
$7.02
Yarok, the Desecrated card image
2bguYarok, the DesecratedLegendary Creature — Elemental HorrorPromo Pack: Core Set 2020
Mythic Rare
220
$6.63
$6.5
Ancient Cellarspawn (Extended Art) card image
Ancient Cellarspawn (Extended Art)enchantment creature — horrorCommander: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Rare
47
-2 %
$6.56
Nemesis of Reason card image
3ubNemesis of ReasonCreature — Leviathan HorrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Rare
1302
$6.26
$6.5
Thing in the Ice card image
1uThing in the IceCreature — HorrorPro Tour Promos
Rare
3
1 %
$6
$11
Eater of the Dead card image
4bEater of the DeadCreature - HorrorThe Dark
Uncommon
44
$5.4
Overlord of the Boilerbilges card image
Overlord of the Boilerbilgesenchantment creature — avatar horrorPromo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Mythic Rare
146
-6 %
$5.1
$5.58
The Gitrog, Ravenous Ride (Extended Art) card image
3bgThe Gitrog, Ravenous Ride (Extended Art)Legendary Creature — Frog Horror MountOutlaws of Thunder Junction
Mythic Rare
352
4 %
$4.95
$7.66
Sauron, the Necromancer (Showcase Scrolls) card image
3bbSauron, the Necromancer (Showcase Scrolls)Legendary Creature — Avatar HorrorThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth
Rare
557
$4.82
$5.13
Cleaver Skaab card image
3uCleaver SkaabCreature — Zombie HorrorCommander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt
rare
11
8 %
$4.77
1
2
EchoMTG ©2026, ThoughtBomb Studios, LLC.Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions. Magic: the Gathering™ references are property of Wizards of the Coast. Lorcana references are property of Disney.