| 2bb | Special | Liliana of the Dark Realms (SDCC 2013 Exclusive) | 74 | | | $2249.50 |
| 0 | Special | Mana Crypt | 6 | 3% | $381.66 / $295.00 | |
| 1rgw | Mythic Rare | Grimlock, Dinobot Leader // Grimlock, Ferocious King | 1 | | | $250.00 |
| 5 | Special | Stocking Tiger (No Date) | 13 | | | $249.99 |
| 4ubr | Special | Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 140 | | | $199.98 |
| 3uu | Special | Jace, Memory Adept (SDCC 2013 Exclusive) | 73 | | | $175.56 |
| 1u | Mythic Rare | Jace, Vryn's Prodigy SDCC 2015 EXCLUSIVE | 60 | | | $162.49 |
| 3bb | Special | Liliana Vess (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | 101 | | | $150.50 |
| 2bb | Mythic Rare | Liliana, Untouched by Death (SDCC 2018 Exclusive) | | | | $150.00 |
| 3gg | Mythic Rare | Nissa, Vital Force (SDCC 2018 Exclusive) | | | | $144.25 |
| 2rr | Mythic Rare | Chandra, Torch of Defiance (SDCC 2018 Exclusive) | | | | $114.99 |
| 2rr | Special | Chandra, Pyromaster (SDCC 2013 Exclusive) | | | | $109.95 |
| 1ww | Special | Ajani, Caller of the Pride (SDCC 2013 Exclusive) | 72 | | | $109.72 |
| 4gg | Special | Garruk, Caller of Beasts (SDCC 2013 Exclusive) | 76 | | | $103.35 |
| 1bb | Mythic Rare | Liliana, the Last Hope SDCC 2016 EXCLUSIVE | | | | $100.62 |
| 1bb | Mythic Rare | Liliana, Heretical Healer SDCC 2015 EXCLUSIVE | 106 | | | $99.99 |
| 2g | Special | Nissa, Vastwood Seer SDCC 2015 EXCLUSIVE | 189 | | | $91.79 |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (5 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S5 | | $82.99 / $79.99 | |
| Special | Chaos Orb (3 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S3 | | $79.99 / $79.99 | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (4 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S4 | | $79.99 / $39.99 | |
| 4gg | Mythic Rare | Garruk, Caller of Beasts SDCC 2013 EXCLUSIVE | | | | $75.54 |
| ubbbr | Special | Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God (SDCC 2019 Exclusive) | | 1% | $74.99 / $70.00 | |
| 1uu | Special | Jace Beleren | 15 | | $62.09 / $45.94 | |
| 3bb | Mythic Rare | Liliana, Death's Majesty (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 97 | | | $60.93 |
| Special | Chaos Orb (2 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S2 | | $59.99 / $59.99 | |
| Special | Chaos Orb (5 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S5 | | $59.99 / $59.99 | |
| 3gg | Special | Nissa, Worldwaker (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | 103 | | | $59.95 |
| 1ww | Mythic Rare | Gideon of the Trials (SDCC 2018 Exclusive) | | | | $52.83 |
| 1rr | Special | Chandra, Fire of Kaladesh SDCC 2015 EXCLUSIVE | 135 | | | $52.19 |
| Special | Chaos Orb (4 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S4 | | $50.00 / $50.00 | |
| 3w | Special | Ajani Steadfast (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | 99 | | | $49.97 |
| 2rr | Mythic Rare | Chandra, Torch of Defiance (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 110 | | | $49.43 |
| 5bg | Special | Garruk, Apex Predator (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | 104 | | | $49.25 |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (8 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S8 | | $48.89 / $39.99 | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (6 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S6 | | $48.69 / $48.69 | |
| 2ww | Mythic Rare | Gideon, Ally of Zendikar (SDCC 2016 Exclusive) | | | | $46.20 |
| 2uu | Mythic Rare | God-Eternal Kefnet SDCC 2019 EXCLUSIVE | 053 | 2% | $46.12 / $35.00 | |
| 3ur | Special | Nerf War | 2 | | | $46.00 |
| Special | Chaos Orb (9 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S9 | | $40.00 / $30.00 | |
| 1gg | Mythic Rare | Nissa, Voice of Zendikar (SDCC 2016 Exclusive) | | | | $40.00 |
| 4rr | Mythic Rare | Chandra, Flamecaller (SDCC 2016 Exclusive) | | | | $39.99 |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (1 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S1 | | $39.99 / $39.99 | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (2 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S2 | | $39.99 / $39.99 | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (7 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S7 | | $39.99 / $39.99 | |
| 3ww | Mythic Rare | God-Eternal Oketra SDCC 2019 EXCLUSIVE | 016 | 4% | $37.99 / $34.09 | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (3 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S3 | | $37.99 / $37.99 | |
| 3 | Special | Sword of Dungeons & Dragons | 3 | | | $37.67 |
| b | Special | Duress (IDW Comics 2014) | 84 | | $37.49 / $31.98 | |
| 2rr | Special | Chandra, Pyromaster (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | | | | $37.48 |
| w | Mythic Rare | Kytheon, Hero of Akros SDCC 2015 EXCLUSIVE | 23 | | | $34.03 |
| 3uu | Mythic Rare | Jace, Unraveler of Secrets (SDCC 2016 Exclusive) | | | | $32.98 |
| 1ww | Mythic Rare | Gideon of the Trials (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 14 | | | $30.00 |
| Special | Chaos Orb (1 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S1 | | $29.99 / $29.99 | |
| Special | Chaos Orb (6 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S6 | | $29.99 / $29.99 | |
| Special | Chaos Orb (8 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S8 | | $29.99 / $29.99 | |
| xgu | Mythic Rare | Nissa, Steward of Elements (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 204 | | | $29.97 |
| 3bb | Mythic Rare | God-Eternal Bontu SDCC 2019 EXCLUSIVE | 092 | 2% | $28.92 / $26.09 | |
| 2uu | Special | Jace, the Living Guildpact (SDCC 2014 Exclusive) | 100 | | | $28.47 |
| 3gg | Mythic Rare | God-Eternal Rhonas SDCC 2019 EXCLUSIVE | 163 | 6% | $26.86 / $24.00 | |
| xgg | Special | Primordial Hydra | 49 | 1% | $25.97 / $19.00 | |
| 3bb | Special | Liliana Vess | P53 | | | $25.72 |
| u | Special | High Tide (IDW Comics 2013) | 80 | | $25.50 / $24.25 | |
| 1uu | Mythic Rare | Jace, Cunning Castaway (SDCC 2018 Exclusive) | | | | $25.00 |
| 2uu | Special | Turnabout (IDW Comics 2012) | 60 | | $23.24 / $19.25 | |
| 3uu | Mythic Rare | Jace, Unraveler of Secrets (SDCC 2017 Exclusive) | 69 | | | $22.99 |
| 4bb | Special | Grave Titan | 35 | | | $21.19 |
| 1bb | Special | Death Baron (2018 Convention Promo) | 90 | | | $20.87 |
| 2rr | Special | Nalathni Dragon | 3 | | $19.99 / $12.99 | |
| 3w | Special | Bonescythe Sliver | 68 | | | $17.45 |
| 2gg | Rare | Nightpack Ambusher (2019 Convention Exclusive) | 185 | | | $17.08 |
| 2gg | Special | Nissa Revane | 27 | | | $16.74 |
| 1ww | Special | Knight Exemplar | 46 | | | $15.30 |
| 2b | Special | Phyrexian Rager | 14 | 95% | $13.22 / $12.02 | |
| 4 | Special | Conqueror's Galleon | 234 | | | $12.95 |
| Special | Arena | 1 | | $9.94 / $7.00 | |
| 1g | Special | Deeproot Champion (2018 Convention Exclusive) | 185 | | | $8.94 |
| Special | Dragon Token (Gold) | 4 | | | $8.75 |
| 1bbb | Special | Vampire Nocturnus | 50 | | $8.69 / $6.25 | |
| 2gg | Special | Garruk Wildspeaker | 16 | | | $8.33 |
| 1rr | Special | Windseeker Centaur | 7 | | $7.97 / $4.89 | |
| 1u | Special | Standstill (IDW Comics 2012) | 57 | 2% | $7.59 / $5.25 | |
| 3uu | Special | Acquire (IDW Comics 2014) | 83 | 2% | $6.68 / $5.57 | |
| 1w | Special | Kor Skyfisher | 25 | | | $6.20 |
| r | Special | Faithless Looting (IDW Comics 2012) | 39 | 1% | $6.13 / $4.24 | |
| x1b | Special | Consume Spirit (IDW Comics 2012) | 54 | 2% | $5.53 / $3.99 | |
| 2u | Special | Stealer of Secrets (2014 Convention Promo) | 89 | | | $5.01 |
| 4rr | Special | Inferno Titan | 36 | | | $4.99 |
| 3u | Special | Wash Out (IDW Comics 2014) | 82 | 21% | $4.98 / $3.80 | |
| xbbg | Special | Gaze of Granite (IDW Comics 2013) | 81 | | $4.75 / $3.42 | |
| 4ww | Special | Felidar Sovereign | 026/274 | | | $4.22 |
| 2u | Special | Aeronaut Tinkerer (2015 Convention Promo) | 043 | | | $4.00 |
| 1r | Special | Scent of Cinder | 9 | | $3.79 / $1.03 | |
| 1ur | Special | Electrolyze (IDW Comics 2012) | 42 | | $3.52 / $1.12 | |
| 5b | Special | Corrupt (IDW Comics 2013) | 64 | | $3.47 / $1.89 | |
| 3u | Special | Voidmage Husher (IDW Comics 2013) | 62 | | $3.21 / $2.50 | |
| 4g | Special | Spined Wurm | 11 | | $2.67 / $0.41 | |
| 1g | Special | Scavenging Ooze | 70 | | | $2.66 |
| 4rr | Rare | Lathliss, Dragon Queen | | | | $2.61 |
| gw | Special | Steward of Valeron | 21 | | | $2.49 |
| 4rr | Rare | Etali, Primal Storm | 100 | | | $2.40 |
| 2gg | Rare | Beast Whisperer | 123 | | | $2.30 |
| 4uu | Special | Frost Titan | 34 | | | $2.14 |
| u | Special | Blue Elemental Blast | 5 | | $2.10 / $1.02 | |
| 1b | Special | Feast of Blood (IDW Comics 2012) | 43 | | $2.02 / $1.69 | |
| 3ggg | Rare | Gargos, Vicious Watcher | 172 | | | $2.00 |
| 1u | Special | Treasure Hunt (IDW Comics 2012) | 38 | 2% | $2.00 / $0.74 | |
| 4www | Special | Serra Avatar | 48 | | $1.97 / $1.25 | |
| 1b | Special | Bloodthrone Vampire | 31 | | | $1.89 |
| xr | Special | Fireball | 4 | | $1.87 / $0.84 | |
| 2rr | Special | Ogre Battledriver | 69 | | | $1.49 |
| 3br | Special | Breath of Malfegor (IDW Comics 2012) | 58 | | $1.46 / $1.00 | |
| 1u | Special | Merfolk Mesmerist | 45 | | | $1.40 |
| 1gg | Special | Giant Badger | 8 | | $1.39 / $1.00 | |
| 4r | Special | Ogre Arsonist (IDW Comics 2013) | 63 | | $1.26 / $0.89 | |
| 2w | Special | Arrest (IDW Comics 2012) | 53 | 14% | $1.22 / $0.44 | |
| 4r | Special | Chandra's Fury | 65 | | | $1.21 |
| 6gg | Special | Terastodon | 52 | | | $1.18 |
| 4ww | Special | Angelic Skirmisher | 90 | | | $1.12 |
| 5ww | Special | Angel of Glory's Rise | 59 | | | $0.97 |
| xgg | Special | Genesis Hydra | | | | $0.96 |
| 4ww | Special | Sunblast Angel | 47 | | | $0.96 |
| 2bb | Special | Sewers of Estark | 2 | -1% | $0.96 / $0.43 | |
| 1rr | Special | Jaya Ballard, Task Mage | 18 | | | $0.90 |
| 3brg | Special | Broodmate Dragon | 19 | | | $0.82 |
| 2rw | Special | Brion Stoutarm | 17 | | | $0.64 |
| 4uu | Special | Soul of Ravnica | 87 | | | $0.61 |
| 3ww | Rare | Thalia's Lancers | 47 | | | $0.56 |
| 4gg | Special | Soul of Zendikar | 88 | | | $0.54 |
| 3r | Special | Warmonger | 12 | | | $0.52 |
| 2rr | Special | Lightning Hounds | 10 | | | $0.50 |
| 2gg | Rare | Bristling Hydra | 147 | | | $0.49 |
| 1rgw | Special | Retaliator Griffin | 24 | | | $0.49 |
| 2b | Special | Xathrid Necromancer | A12 | | | $0.48 |
| 1wu | Common | Silver Drake | 13 | | $0.40 / $0.40 | |
| 6r | Special | Hamletback Goliath | 71 | | | $0.34 |
| 2uu | Rare | Curator of Mysteries | 049 | | | $0.31 |
| 2gg | Special | Nightpack Ambusher | 185 | | | |
| w | Special | Loam Lion (Japanese Promo) | 11 | | | |
| 1b | Special | Cast Down (JP Magazine Promo) | 001 | | | |
| r | Special | Shock (JP Graphic Novel Insert) | 001 | | | |
| b | Special | Duress (JP Graphic Novel Insert) | 001 | | | |
| 1rr | Special | Goblin Chieftain (Japanese Promo) | 141 | | | |
| 2rr | Special | Nalathni Dragon (Redemption Program) | 1 | | | |
| 5 | Special | Darksteel Juggernaut (Coro Coro Insert) | 16 | | | |
| 1b | Special | Diabolic Edict (JP Graphic Novel Insert) | 001 | | | |
| Special | Oran-Rief, the Vastwood (Japanese Promo) | 221 | | | |
| Special | Chaos Orb (7 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S7 | | | |
| uw | Special | Staggering Insight (JP Graphic Novel Insert) | 001 | | | |
| 0 | Special | Black Lotus (9 of 9) (Ultra Pro Puzzle Quest) | S9 | | | |