EchoMTG Logo
Dashboard / Home
My Collection
Magic: the Gathering logo
Magic: the Gathering
MTG Expansions
MTG Market
Special Groups
MTG Types
Disney Lorcana logo
Disney Lorcana
My Apps
Lists / Decks
Sealed Manager
Earnings Tracker
Watchlist
Trade List
Statistics
Import Tool
My Account
EchoMTG
Blog
API Docs
Subscription Plans
Login
EchoMTG Logo
Background O,age

Magic: the GatheringMost Expensive Magic: the Gathering nightmares

Top 99 Most Expensive nightmares
Background

Track Prices

Collection tools for Magic: the Gathering, no ads, track a binder worth the cards for free.

Search cards...
Filter by Type
Card Info
Rarity
#
7-day
Regular Price
Foil Price
Nightmare card image
5bNightmareCreature - Nightmare HorseLimited Edition Alpha
Rare
118
$1400
Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER (Borderless) (0317) card image
2bSephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER (Borderless) (0317)legendary creature — human avatar soldier // legendary creature - angel nightmare avatarUniverses Beyond: FINAL FANTASY
Mythic Rare
317
2 %
$65.69
$134.31
Biollante, Plant Beast Form - Nethroi, Apex of Death card image
2wbgBiollante, Plant Beast Form - Nethroi, Apex of DeathLegendary Creature - Cat Nightmare BeastIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
380
$37.29
$34.61
Umbris, Fear Manifest card image
3ubUmbris, Fear Manifestlegendary creature — nightmare horrorSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
2324
4 %
$29.18
Bio-Quartz Spacegodzilla - Brokkos, Apex of Forever card image
2bguBio-Quartz Spacegodzilla - Brokkos, Apex of ForeverLegendary Creature - Nightmare Beast ElementalIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
378
3 %
$27.47
$25.92
King Caesar, Awoken Titan - Snapdax, Apex of the Hunt card image
1rwbKing Caesar, Awoken Titan - Snapdax, Apex of the HuntLegendary Creature - Dinosaur Cat NightmareIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
381
3 %
$10.86
$10.34
Doom Whisperer card image
3bbDoom Whisperercreature — nightmare demonSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
1763
$9.43
Fiend Artisan card image
bbFiend ArtisanCreature — NightmareSecret Lair Drop Series
Mythic Rare
1645
1 %
$8.26
Nethroi, Apex of Death (Showcase) card image
2wbgNethroi, Apex of Death (Showcase)Legendary Creature - Cat Nightmare BeastIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
303
7 %
$5.45
$16.28
Angel of Suffering card image
3bbAngel of SufferingCreature — Nightmare AngelPromo Pack: Streets of New Capenna
Mythic Rare
67
$5.25
$5.01
Braids, Arisen Nightmare (Showcase) card image
1bbBraids, Arisen Nightmare (Showcase)Legendary Creature — NightmareDominaria United
Rare
288
-2 %
$5.09
$6.87
Fear of Missing Out card image
Fear of Missing Outenchantment creature — nightmarePromo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Rare
136
-8 %
$5.06
$6.22
The Mindskinner card image
The Mindskinnerlegendary enchantment creature — nightmarePromo Pack: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Rare
66
$4.23
$2.68
Spacegodzilla, Death Corona - Void Beckoner card image
6bbSpacegodzilla, Death Corona - Void BeckonerCreature - Nightmare HorrorIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Uncommon
373
1 %
$3.96
$4.21
Dread Presence card image
3bDread PresenceCreature — NightmareJumpstart 2022
rare
403
-3 %
$3.75
Mesmeric Fiend card image
1bMesmeric FiendCreature - Nightmare HorrorDuel Decks: Sorin vs. Tibalt
Common
7
9 %
$3.74
Brokkos, Apex of Forever (Showcase) card image
2bguBrokkos, Apex of Forever (Showcase)Legendary Creature - Nightmare Beast ElementalIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
299
-5 %
$3.27
$5.24
Lurrus of the Dream-Den (Extended Art) card image
1wbwbLurrus of the Dream-Den (Extended Art)Legendary Creature - Cat NightmareIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Rare
355
-3 %
$3.09
$5.55
Zaxara, the Exemplary card image
1bguZaxara, the ExemplaryLegendary Creature — Nightmare HydraCommander 2020
Mythic Rare
20
2 %
$3.06
$3.44
Tayam, Luminous Enigma card image
1wbgTayam, Luminous EnigmaLegendary Creature — Nightmare beastCommander 2020
Mythic Rare
16
3 %
$2.2
$1.24
Worldgorger Dragon card image
3rrrWorldgorger DragonCreature — Nightmare DragonDominaria Remastered
mythic
148
8 %
$2.01
$1.87
Ultimecia, Time Sorceress (Extended Art) card image
3ubUltimecia, Time Sorceress (Extended Art)legendary creature — human warlock // legendary creature — nightmare warlockUniverses Beyond: FINAL FANTASY
Uncommon
513
16 %
$1.81
$14.02
Jecht, Reluctant Guardian (Borderless) card image
3bJecht, Reluctant Guardian (Borderless)legendary creature — human warrior // legendary enchantment creature — saga nightmareUniverses Beyond: FINAL FANTASY
Rare
363
7 %
$1.74
$3.19
Hypnox card image
8bbbHypnoxCreature - Nightmare HorrorTorment
Rare
64
-2 %
$1.54
$37.47
Otrimi, the Ever-Playful card image
3bguOtrimi, the Ever-PlayfulLegendary Creature — Nightmare BeastCommander 2020
Mythic Rare
12
1 %
$1.49
$0.83
Snapdax, Apex of the Hunt (Showcase) card image
1rwbSnapdax, Apex of the Hunt (Showcase)Legendary Creature - Dinosaur Cat NightmareIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Mythic Rare
306
-7 %
$1
$2.79
Fear of Sleep Paralysis (Extended Art) card image
Fear of Sleep Paralysis (Extended Art)enchantment creature — nightmareCommander: Duskmourn: House of Horror
Rare
43
-14 %
$1
Slitherwisp (Extended Art) card image
ubbSlitherwisp (Extended Art)Creature - Elemental NightmareIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Rare
345
3 %
$0.98
$1.12
Silvar, Devourer of the Free card image
3brSilvar, Devourer of the FreeLegendary Creature — Cat NightmareCommander 2020
Mythic Rare
15
2 %
$0.88
$0.48
Cruel Somnophage card image
1bCruel SomnophageCreature — NightmarePromo Pack: Wilds of Eldraine
Rare
222
$0.85
$1.02
Laquatus's Champion card image
4bbLaquatus's ChampionCreature- Nightmare HorrorTorment
Rare
67
$0.75
$26.99
Ovika, Enigma Goliath card image
5urOvika, Enigma GoliathLegendary Creature — Phyrexian NightmarePromo Pack: Phyrexian: All Will Be One
Rare
213
$0.69
$1.69
Labyrinth Raptor (Extended Art) card image
brLabyrinth Raptor (Extended Art)Creature - Nightmare DinosaurIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Rare
339
$0.66
$0.96
Kathril, Aspect Warper card image
2wbgKathril, Aspect WarperLegendary Creature — Nightmare InsectCommander 2020
Mythic Rare
10
$0.63
$0.75
Nightmare Token card image
Nightmare TokenToken Creature — NightmareTheros Beyond Death Tokens
Token
12
12 %
$0.57
Wormfang Manta card image
5uuWormfang MantaCreature - Nightmare Fish BeastJudgment
Rare
58
$0.56
$11.46
Mindleecher card image
4bbMindleecherCreature — NightmareCommander 2020
rare
44
-6 %
$0.56
Dream Eater card image
4uuDream EaterCreature - Nightmare SphinxGuilds of Ravnica
Mythic Rare
38
$0.5
$0.82
Hunted Nightmare (Extended Art) card image
1bbHunted Nightmare (Extended Art)Creature - NightmareIkoria: Lair of Behemoths
Rare
322
$0.48
$0.39
Wormfang Behemoth card image
3uuWormfang BehemothCreature - Nightmare Fish BeastJudgment
Rare
55
$0.47
$3.38
Soulgorger Orgg card image
3rrSoulgorger OrggCreature - Nightmare OrggJudgment
Uncommon
99
$0.47
$5.74
Petradon card image
6rrPetradonCreature - Nightmare BeastTorment
Rare
108
3 %
$0.45
$5.15
Faceless Butcher card image
2bbFaceless ButcherCreature - Nightmare HorrorTime Spiral "Timeshifted"
Special
43
-4 %
$0.4
$0.99
Haunt of the Dead Marshes (Showcase Scrolls) card image
bHaunt of the Dead Marshes (Showcase Scrolls)Creature — Nightmare ElfThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth
Common
541
$0.4
$0.4
Dream Beavers card image
Dream Beaverscreature — beaver nightmareTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Uncommon
62
3 %
$0.39
Leyline Prowler card image
1bgLeyline ProwlerCreature — Nightmare BeastCommander 2021
Uncommon
222
6 %
$0.36
Carnival Hellsteed card image
4brCarnival HellsteedCreature - Nightmare HorseRavnica Allegiance: Guild Kits
Rare
62
$0.35
Wormfang Crab card image
3uWormfang CrabCreature - Nightmare CrabJudgment
Uncommon
56
$0.3
$0.53
Vitality Hunter card image
3wVitality HunterCreature — NightmareCommander 2020
rare
30
15 %
$0.3
Falthis, Shadowcat Familiar card image
2bFalthis, Shadowcat FamiliarLegendary Creature — Nightmare CatCommander Legends
Uncommon
126
14 %
$0.29
$0.31
1
2
EchoMTG ©2026, ThoughtBomb Studios, LLC.Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions. Magic: the Gathering™ references are property of Wizards of the Coast. Lorcana references are property of Disney.